Brownsville Secure Storage vs Extra Space Storage (Padre Island Hwy)
Facility details checked October 20, 2026.
Which is better, Brownsville Secure Storage or Extra Space Storage?
It depends on what is being stored. The two are 1.3 miles apart on Highway 48. For furniture, tools, boxed household goods and business stock, Brownsville Secure Storage has drive-up units, a gate open 24 hours where Extra Space closes at 10pm, and no activation or admin fee; in October 2026 its 10×10 was $68 a month against $102 at Extra Space's web rate. For things that need climate control, Extra Space at 5680 S Padre Island Hwy is the one to pick: every unit it lists is indoor and climate controlled, and it is a national chain with a staffed office.
Where each one is
Both are on Highway 48 (S Padre Island Hwy) on the east side of Brownsville. Brownsville Secure Storage is at 6935 S Padre Island Hwy, half a mile from FM 802; Extra Space is at 5680 S Padre Island Hwy, 1.3 miles toward town. Typical drive times from Google Maps:
| Facility | Downtown (Market Square) | UTRGV | Port of Brownsville |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brownsville Secure Storage | 16 min | 15 min | 5 min |
| Extra Space, Padre Island Hwy | 13 min | 12 min | 7 min |
Google Distance Matrix, October 20, 2026, from each landmark to each facility.
Side by side
| Facility | Google rating | From downtown | Unit access | Climate control | Drive-up |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brownsville Secure Storage 6935 S Padre Island Hwy | 4.7 (14 reviews) | 5.3 mi | 24 hours, every day | No | Yes, every unit |
| Month to month, no ID needed, no activation or admin fee, lock available | |||||
| Extra Space Storage (Padre Island Hwy) 5680 S Padre Island Hwy | 5.0 (41 reviews) | 4.0 mi | 6am to 10pm daily | Yes, every unit listed | None listed (indoor units) |
| National chain. 1.3 mi from Brownsville Secure Storage on the same highway. Office 9:30am to 6pm. In-store rate about 40% above its web rate | |||||
Current prices for Brownsville Secure Storage are on the prices page. Facility details are from each facility's own website and Google listing, checked October 20, 2026. Details change, so confirm before renting. Sources: Extra Space Storage (Padre Island Hwy).
Brownsville Secure Storage
6935 S Padre Island Hwy (Highway 48), east Brownsville, half a mile from FM 802 and 5 minutes from the Port of Brownsville
- Run by
- An independent operator, not a national chain
- Google rating
- 4.7 out of 5 from 14 Google reviews
- Unit access
- 24 hours a day, every day
- Office
- Calls and texts answered daily, 8:00 AM to 8:00 PM Central (9 to 9 Eastern)
- Unit types
- Ground-level drive-up units, each with its own roll-up door
- Sizes
- 5×10, 10×10, 10×20 and 10×30, plus a single 20×20
- Fees
- No activation or admin fee
- Renting
- Online or by text. Month to month, no ID needed, a lock available
- Good to know
- Cameras day and night. A first-month price shown online is applied automatically
- Best for
- Furniture, household goods, tools and business stock that need to be reachable at any hour
Pros
- Gate open 24 hours, every day, at no extra charge
- Every unit is drive-up, with its own roll-up door
- No activation or admin fee
- Month to month, no ID needed, lock available
- First month discounted when rented online
- 5 minutes from the port, on the road to Port Isabel
Cons
- No climate-controlled units
Extra Space Storage (Padre Island Hwy)
5680 S Padre Island Hwy, on Highway 48, 1.3 miles toward town from Brownsville Secure Storage
- Run by
- Extra Space Storage, a national chain
- Google rating
- 5.0 from 41 reviews
- Unit access
- 6am to 10pm daily
- Office
- On site, 9:30am to 6pm on the day it was checked
- Unit types
- Indoor, climate controlled; no drive-up units listed
- Sizes
- Includes 10×15 and 15×15
- Good to know
- Its in-store rate was about 40% above its web rate
- Best for
- Climate control on the east side of town
Pros
- Climate control on every unit listed
- On-site office
- National chain with corporate backing
- More sizes, including 10×15
Cons
- No drive-up units listed
- Access ends at 10pm
- In-store rate well above the web rate
Where Brownsville Secure Storage has the edge
Drive-up units. Every unit has its own roll-up door at ground level, so a truck backs up and unloads straight in. Gate open 24 hours a day, which helps for shift work at the port or loading before a storm. A lower monthly rate for the same floor space, with the first month discounted online. No activation or admin fee, month to month, no ID needed, and a lock available. Calls and texts to (956) 382-6404 are answered daily, 8:00 AM to 8:00 PM Central (9 to 9 Eastern).
Where Extra Space has the edge
Climate control on every unit it lists, which matters in Brownsville's heat and humidity for wood furniture, electronics, papers and photos. A staffed office, 9:30am to 6pm on the day it was checked. More sizes, including 10×15 and 15×15. And it is a national chain with corporate backing and many locations.
Watch the in-store rate
Extra Space shows two prices for each unit: a web rate and an in-store rate. In October 2026 a 10×10 there was $102 online against $143 in store, so renting online is the way to get its lower rate.
What Brownsville Secure Storage does not have
Climate-controlled units. For things that need climate control, Extra Space is a good choice. The page on climate control in Brownsville covers which things need it.
More facilities are compared in the Brownsville storage guide, and the current price for every size at Brownsville Secure Storage is on the prices page.
See live availability and current prices, or call and a person here will get you set up.
See units and sizes